‘All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing’
A study of a Web quota
Martin Porter
January 2002
The Henrik Hudson School District Library Media Centre provides a model essay for students which ends with the words,
Perpetrators, collaborators, bystanders, victims: we can be clear about three of these categories. The bystander, however, is the fulcrum. If there are enough notable exceptions, then protest reaches a critical mass. We don’t usually think of history as being shaped by silence, but, as English philosopher Edmund Burke said, ‘The only thing necessary for the triumph [of evil] is for good men to do nothing.’
I know many of you have heard this quote before, but I would like to apply it to the epidemic rise that we are seeing in teen suicides, and school shootings that are being attributed to the phenomenon known as “bullying”. I know some of you get tired of hearing about the “bullying” issues, and feel that they are being addressed ad nauseam. You may also feel that the label is used by parents or kids as an “excuse”, to explain why they can’t handle certain situations in a better or different way. After all, we were “teased” growing up, and survived. It didn’t seem to hurt any of us, and after all, what doesn’t kill you, makes you stronger, right? The news is riddled with situations where bullying seems at the fore-front. Just recently there was a school shooting in Nevada, and a young girl in Florida committed suicide. Both situations were linked to bullying.
I can tell you as a parent that has dealt with these issues concerning our own sons, one cannot truly understand the severity of what happens to a child that has to endure this kind of “teasing” day after day, until you have actually lived through it. I will tell you that it is not just ordinary “teasing”. It is vicious, hurtful, and can completely change who a person is. Those who are cowards, can use the internet, to further harm and damage a person while remaining anonymous. I stood by and watched as our handsome, wonderful sons changed from being confident individuals (proud of who they were), into being insecure (not finding one thing they liked about themselves anymore), and just wanting to die. As a parent, it just breaks your heart. You put all your time and energy into raising confident, caring, successful young men, only to see that stripped away, and destroyed. While in the meantime, feeling so helpless in how to help your child get through their turmoil and struggles.
One of the worst things that can happen is, when the school is made aware of what is going on, and they do NOTHING to help you or your child resolve this issue. I know this happened to us. It finally came to the point where we removed our boys from school, and I had to home-school them. I home-schooled them, until we could transfer them into a better school, where the administration and teachers actually cared enough about the students to create a safe environment where bullying in any way shape or form was not tolerated.
Because our boys are on the autism spectrum, it is very hard for them to actually verbalize to us what is happening to them. As they were being home-schooled, and felt safe, they were able to open up and share with me some of what had happened to them. When I wrote the letter for them to have a change of school assignment, and was sending in all my documentation, I asked our son (who had endured the worst of the bullying), if he could sit down and write a letter to them explaining how he felt. He was able to put this down in 2009. I asked him if I could share it, and he told me that I could. It always makes me cry when I read it, because I know it doesn’t even begin to scratch the surface of what he endured.
Dear MVMS,
When I started at Diamond Elementary in the 5th grade, I was very shy and quiet, but Mr. Hunter and Ms. Burney helped me to become confident, able to share my opinions in class without feeling embarrassed. And, most importantly, I could write a great paragraph and long stories, and I could play gym and recess with the other kids without being called names. I won the Presidential Award for Academic Excellence. So I was very excited to go to middle school here. And when we went to the Open House, I felt like this would be almost like Diamond. But school stopped being fun. I felt like I stopped going to school, instead I was going to a prison camp. I was pushed in the hallway, called names, and worst of all, someone threw my books in the toilet. I started home-schooling on November 14, because I just couldn’t take it anymore. My mom and dad and brothers made me feel confident enough to try again this year. But, as bad as 6th grade was, 7th grade was at least 10 times worse! I had breakdowns almost every day in English because the teacher forced me into standing up in front of the class and speaking, but I couldn’t do it. She made me stand there while the kids laughed at me, and then sent me back to my seat with a 0, and I was embarrassed and humiliated. And when I couldn’t write a paper, I had to stay during lunch. But I was in so big a breakdown, it lasted until right before gym. Then when I went to gym, the other kids wouldn’t let me play and I got called names. When I told the teachers about some of the name-calling, the kids denied it, and the teachers believed them. So I continued to get tortured until the final week before Christmas break, because then my mom home-schooled me again. I wasn’t in MVMS for a year, yet I don’t ever want to go through those doors again! I want a fresh start and a new school, so I can enjoy school again. Sincerely, (our son)
Just last year, our son was still struggling with some self-esteem issues that have stemmed from being bullied, when I asked him a question. I asked him what was harder to get over… what the kids called him (gay, faggot, f..ing idiot, etc.), or what they had done to him. His answer shocked me. He told me that it wasn’t so much what the kids had said or done, but because of the teachers. I asked him what he meant by that. He told me because when he asked for help, they did nothing. So my quote I used earlier is maybe not so much geared towards the kids, but to you teachers, and adults out there. Teachers and adults can bully just as much as other students can. Kids learn behaviors from watching us. We need to set the example. The greatest tragedy that can happen when we see a kid in need, is to do nothing. I challenge you today, to at least do something.
Written by Kim Carlisle